Sunday, June 9th 2013 at 12:45 pm

OMG, GMOs!
You might ask, "why all the fuss about agricultural genetically
modified organisms (GMOs)?" After all, regulatory agencies have approved
these technologies for widespread application and consumption, so they
must be safe, right? Well, the truth is that there is no agency and no
industry that works to protect our
health. At best, the EPA, USDA, and FDA attempt to respond to our
disease
after the cause is widespread. At that point only risk reduction,
rather than risk avoidance, can be achieved. This has been the case
historically with radium paint, tobacco, particulate air pollution,
water pollution, asbestos, lead, food-borne illnesses, and DDT. A
number of the various 80,000 chemicals in production will likely be
added to this list in the future while the majority of them that
actually do contribute to disease (often in combination and in complex
ways) will never be scientifically associated with disease. This is
because science is far from perfect, scientific methodology is always
biased and often manipulated, and scientific interpretation by
stakeholders and decision makers is alarmingly inept (I'm not being
political or condescending, these are well known and easily observed
facts).
The situation with agricultural GMOs is unique compared to other technologies. While
genetic engineering of food crops
has been ongoing for 15 years, it is currently experiencing a major
boom with the potential for widespread worldwide application. Yet, few
people understand how a GMO food could really be so much different than a
non-GMO food in regard to health and disease effects. GMO foods look
like non-GMO foods and so we don't experience the same hesitation and
aversion to consuming them like we would, say, a clearly labeled bottle
of virus and pesticide in tomato juice. Therefore, the quality of
public education, consumer awareness, and informed public discussion
about this technology has the potential to alter the future of GMO
agriculture for better or worse.
In this article, I'll first briefly mention the relative paucity of
risk assessment studies on GMOs and the unbelievable weaknesses of the
industry studies
that have been done. Then, drawing from numerous independent studies, I
will explore the routes by which agricultural GMOs may cause adverse
health effects.
GMOs Have Never Been "Proven" Safe
Let me be clear; despite the following negative review of industry
science, this article is not a hatchet job against the agricultural GMO
industry but, rather, a vehicle for consolidated scientific information
on the safety or risks of GMO foods intended to allow readers to make
informed choices about this technology. It is just that, well, the
science coming from the industry tends to raise serious concerns and
suggests that the agricultural GMO industry has little concern for
protecting public and ecosystem health. Before we dive into the
independent non-industry studies which suggest potential harm from GMO
crops and foods, we must first look at the studies which supposedly
demonstrate the safety of GMO crops and foods. A critique of these
studies remained impossible for some time as the data was kept private,
until French researchers obtained a court order for their release. This
team of researchers, lead by Joel Spiroux de Vendomois, then analyzed
the raw data from studies on three varieties of GMO corn owned by
Monsanto. Yet, it immediately became apparent that this data was not
extremely helpful as the study methodology was profoundly insufficient.
In a 2010 paper published in the International Journal of Biological
Sciences
[1], the researchers summarize several major flaws in the study. I'll list just a few of them here:
1. For each of the three varieties of GMO corn tested, only a single
study was done. However, a central tenet of sound science is that the
results are reproducible and replicated by other studies, preferably
those done by different researchers.
2. Only the rat was used as a toxicological model. Rats are useful
models for the human detoxification systems, but poor models for human
reproductive and embryological systems. Remember, rat studies "proved"
that thalidomide was safe for pregnant women to use... but the rabbit
studies done AFTER thousands of babies were harmed "proved" that it
caused birth defects! Scientific proof is only as good as the
scientific studies, which are always limited and narrowly focused.
3. The studies lasted only 3 months and were done on young adult
rats. Yet, captive rats live about 24 months. No studies looking at
late life outcomes from this brief exposure or studies which used
lifelong exposure to GMOs were performed. This is clearly a problem
unless human consumers are only supposed to eat GMO foods for no longer
than 9 years between the ages of 10 and 20. Yet, GMO food technology
has been released (without labeling) with the intention of lifelong
consumption.
4. No reproductive or developmental studies were done. Yet GMO
foods do not carry a label declaring that their safety during pregnancy
has not been evaluated. Instead, they are unlabeled and meant to be
consumed by both genders, at all ages and developmental stages,
including during pregnancy and infancy.
5. Adverse outcomes were only considered if they occurred in both
genders! Clearly genders are different. For instance, women are much
more likely to get breast cancer than men, and one must have a prostate
to get prostate cancer. In the industry studies, increases in prostate
cancer in male rats and increases in mammary tumors in female rats would
apparently have been omitted since they differed between genders. This
explains exactly what happened to their findings that male rats eating
GMO corn had an 11% increase in heart size while female rats eating GMO
corn had a 40% increase in serum triglycerides
[2].
It is not clear what to make of these findings, but they should not
have been omitted and, instead, should have been used to encourage more
numerous and longer duration (lifespan) studies before the worldwide
release of GMO corn.
6. Adverse outcomes which are consider "normal" in old rats were
omitted in this young rat population. For instance, the researchers did
not consider "chronic progressive nephropathy", a kidney disease common
in older rats, to be a problem even though it was occurring in young, 5
month old, rats eating the GMO corn.
Now, I can attest that modern toxicology students training at
respectable universities are taught to do much better work than this. We
can only speculate about the reasons such limited study methodologies
were chosen. Nonetheless, these are the studies which the FDA
determined to be sufficient for the approval of the three GMO corn
varieties represented. As if the major flaws in the study methodologies
were not enough to warrant a different decision, the French team of
researchers found a number of concerning associations upon re-analyzing
the raw data
[3]. They summarize:
"Our analysis clearly reveals for the 3
GMOs new side effects linked with GM maize consumption, which were sex-
and often dose-dependent. Effects were mostly associated with the kidney
and liver, the dietary detoxifying organs, although different between
the 3 GMOs. Other effects were also noticed in the heart, adrenal
glands, spleen and hematopoietic system. We conclude that these data
highlight signs of hepatorenal toxicity, possibly due to the new
pesticides specific to each GM corn."
This is not the only group of researchers to demonstrate an
association between GMO consumption and adverse health outcomes.
Despite the industries resistance to providing GMO varieties to outside
researchers for independent studies, there are still dozens of studies
available to the public for review. I'll synthesize the findings of
several of these studies below in considering the possible mechanisms by
which agricultural GMOs may cause problems. In general, the health
effects of agricultural GMOs are mediated through at least three routes;
1. Directly though ingestion, 2. Indirectly through
GMO associated pesticide exposure and ingestion, and 3. Indirectly through environmental and ecosystem effects.
Effects of GMO ingestion:
Ingesting GMOs can affect both the microbiome and human cells. The
microbiome is the microorganism population which lives on and in the
human body. Most of it exists in or on the mouth, nose, stomach,
intestines, and skin. The gut microbiome has received considerable
attention due to its apparently profound effect on the immune system,
not to mention its effect on food digestion. The gut microbiome is
involved in determining the risk of autoimmune diseases, allergic
diseases, cardiovascular disease, and some infectious diseases like
osteomyelitis. The microbiome can get out of balance (called
dysbiosis)
and produce severe diseases such as Clostridium difficile overgrowth
and more mild disorders like small bowel bacterial overgrowth and
irritable bowel syndrome. The bottom line is that a balanced microbiome
is critical for health and we are just now beginning to appreciate how
serious the consequences of dysbiosis may be.
Several studies have shown that the organisms (mostly bacteria) of the microbiome can take up genes from GMO foods
[4],
[5].
"Conjugation", or gene transfer, is a common trick used by bacteria to
evolve and adapt. This is one mechanism by which antibiotic resistance
perpetuates. The consequences of GMO gene transfer to intestinal
bacteria involve the expression of the gene and/or insertional
mutagenesis. The frequency with which these consequences will occur is
not known, but they will occur to some degree at least.
Intestinal bacteria which begin to express the GMO gene will then be
producing the same active proteins which define the GMO. For example,
intestinal bacteria could start producing the Bacillus thuringiensis
(Bt) pesticidal toxin that has been inserted into potatoes, corn, and
soybeans. The exact effect of this toxin on humans, if any, is not well
established but it has been found in a study of Canadian women,
including pregnant women and their fetuses
[6].
Insertional mutagenesis refers to the gene inserting itself into
another coding gene and, thus, causing a gene mutation by disrupting the
code. This may produce more severe results as it is a well known
mechanism by which viruses may cause cancer, cell death, or cellular
dysfunction.
These same mechanisms, gene transfer and insertional mutagenesis, can
affect human cells just the same. While intestinal cells are likely to
be the most affected, GMO genes which pass into the blood intact may
affect just about any cell and tissue in the body. It is quite possible
that GMO foods are regularly resulting in the genetic modification of
the humans consuming them! There are many unknowns here and I suspect
that there remains a lot to be discovered, but we should not let the
absence of evidence be mistaken for the evidence of absent harm. We
should, instead, demand more information and more research!
Read Full Article Here